9 Jun 2012

Fad Diets

There are a large number of fad diets which continue to flood our markets and minds with the promise of helping us ‘lose a stone in 2 weeks’ or ‘shed pounds fast’. They are promoted as a ‘health product’ and a quick, nutritious alternative to simply eating healthily; but are these diets as good for us as they claim to be? What effects do they have on our long term health, and what are the short term side effects?



We’ve had Alli diet pills, Slimming World’s meal replacement shakes, the Atkins and even bowel cleansing juice fasts, too often promoted by popular public figures.

Most recently, one which seems to be extremely popular is ‘The Master Cleanse’, a diet of lemonade and maple syrup, made famous by celebrities such as Beyoncé. I have been approached by not only clients, but friends and even my sister claiming they are about to embark on this ‘amazing’ weight loss detox.

Having heard so much about it, I decided it was time I researched a little further. I must say, the website does a fantastic job in convincing it’s audience that this is not only a fantastic aid for weight loss, but also nutritious and colon friendly.

The diet is split into 3 stages: #1 the Ease in; #2 the Lemonade Diet & Salt Water Flush; #3 the Ease Out

Phase 1, the ‘Ease In’ lasts for just 3 days – hardly enough time to introduce yourself to such an extreme form of dieting if you ask me! On day one you are allowed to eat raw fruits and vegetables only (this will seem easy to most people), on day two you must consume no solid foods and instead drink freshly made raw fruit and veg juices; finally on day three you have a 1.5litre allowance of orange juice which you may mix with water, no other juices or foods are to be consumed (rich in vitamin c, but not much else).

The website recommends you follow Phase 2 for 10 days, but claims it is perfectly healthy to follow this stage for as long as 1 year!!! This phase consists of drinking 6-12 glasses of ‘Lemonade’ and 1 litre of salt water per day. Each glass of lemonade consists of 2 tablespoons of dark maple syrup, 2 tablespoons of lemon juice and one tenth of a teaspoon of cayenne pepper mixed with water; I can’t even begin to imagine what that must taste like.



The salt water flush is made from 2 teaspoons of sea salt mixed with 1 litre of water to be drunk in one sitting. This acts as a fast-working laxative, so it is imperative to keep a toilet nearby for up to 2 hours after drinking! Salt water is renowned for causing dehydration; hence if you were stranded at sea, you could be surrounded by water but unable to drink.

Finally phase 3 is a reversed version of the ‘Ease In’. Day one allows just orange juice and water, day two allows juices only and day three allows a raw fruit and veg diet.

How anyone can follow such an extreme diet lacking in any form of nutrients is beyond me! Low calorie diets such as this will cause extreme side effects such as headaches, nausea and dehydration; the lack of nutrients can cause illness and leave the person feeling week. As for the long term effects of yo-yo dieting or starvation fasts; health issues include but are not limited to heart disease and diabetes.


 How on earth Beyoncé, who is renowned for her active lifestyle and long dance rehearsals, existed on this product intrigues me; as an active person myself who usually dances for 3 hrs per day, sometimes more I could not imagine in the slightest how I would maintain my energy living off a low-calorie drink. I had heard of trainers following their clients extreme diets before (not usually lasting very long of course); always one for a challenge, I decided to embark on the ‘Master Cleanse’ so that once and for all, when I tell people how bad it is for them I can say it with confidence and experience.

So I have made it my priority to share my experiences of this ‘experiment’ over the 10 days; to share with people my energy levels, daily struggles and my final thoughts after putting this product to the test. Apprehensive isn’t even the word!!

Day 1 had me thinking “Seriously, what have I got myself into?” It was the first day of the salt water flush and my juice-only diet, meaning I will not (or should not) eat a solid food for the following 10 days. I had now embarked on my experiment of drinking just water, lemon juice, maple syrup and cayenne pepper, also known as the 'lemonade master cleanse'..

Each morning I have been, and will continue to make video diaries of my progress. On the morning of day one I woke up not too long after sunrise, meditated, drank the salt water and did some gentle exercises. I could feel my stomach bubbling away, and was quite frankly petrified to experience the results.



The whole idea of the salt water flush is to eliminate your digestive tract of any toxins, clear hard faeces and generally 'detox'. It is used in many complimentary health medicines, and the idea is that in the same way salt water can be used to heal an external wound, by absorbing toxicities, it can be used to absorb any toxins within the bowel.

I eat a very healthy and clean diet which contains many fruits and vegetables, yet I, like a large number of people in the world suffer from digestive problems and blocked colon; laxatives rarely help, only an increase of fruit may ease it at times, so I was intrigued to see what affect this salt water has on me!

Day 2 of the lemonade diet saw the side effects starting to kick in - not good!

I had intended to share one video a day to diarise my progress, but on day one I found myself making 5 or 6 small videos, perhaps as a subconscious way of keeping myself motivated. It was then that I decided I would edit all the raw footage at the end of this process to produce a short documentary on the dangers of fad diets and extreme detoxes.

Today is ‘day 3’ of the lemonade diet, I have now gone without food for almost 4 days (including the ease in). I feel awful – tired, weak, exhausted.

The problem is, we have an issue here, and that issue is vitamin deficiency. Having not had any food pass my lips for 4 days, my body is seriously lacking in nutrients; multivitamins require solid food within the body in order for them to be absorbed, so even as an alternative source, they are out of the question.


Many illnesses and diseases are linked to vitamin deficiency – even cancer! My concern with this diet is that people, who are on it, are setting themselves up for numerous trips to the doctors. It may not make them ill straight away, but most certainly will have a long term effect on their health.

I always liken our bodies to cars; if you fill a petrol car with diesel, it will break down; our bodies are exactly the same. We require natural sources of food – fruit, vegetables, meat – if we take one of those away or do not eat any, our body will shut down. I am desperate to eat some fruit and vegetables!

My friend claimed I am like a Polar bear; many animals go into hibernation during the months that food is scarce; our bodies very similarly become weak and tired if we do not eat, it is as if we are going into hibernation mode where we need to sleep in order for our bodies to repair the damage which we are doing to it.

It is our natural animal instinct to eat food; it is why we have teeth, to bite and to chew. Last nigh, my fiancé was eating pistachios, and subconsciously I picked one out the bag, cracked open the shell and popped it in my mouth. It was only when I went to bite into it did we both realise what I was doing. I spat it out, as I am determined to follow this diet as strictly as possible in an attempt to prove how bad fad diets are.

I have said however, that if it gets to a point where I NEED to eat in fear of collapsing, then I will.

My morning video diaries are being uploaded to my facebook page, the rest are being kept private and will be used exclusively for my end product. Click here to check them out: http://www.facebook.com/pages/Deanna-Kayla/341206682590294